Is The Customer the Hero of Your Brand Journey?
Home/Insights/Customer Onboarding: One Chance for a First Experience
Customer Experience

Customer Onboarding: One Chance for a First Experience

A company has only one opportunity to make a first impression. The minute a new customer engages with your brand, the onboarding process should start — and it should start before they even pay.

Salena ScardinaSalena Scardina
··7 min read
Customer Experience

Customer Onboarding: One Chance for a First Experience

A company has only one opportunity to make a first impression. The minute a new customer engages with your brand, the onboarding process should start — and it should start before they even pay.

S
Salena Scardina
••7 min read
Customer Onboarding: One Chance for a First Experience

When I walk into one of my favorite spas about three times a year for a massage, I'm usually about an hour early. The intentionality of the spa, with soft music in the background, the faint scent of sandalwood, and a calming atmosphere, creates an incredible oasis. I can almost feel the stress begin to slip away just by being in this special environment and experiencing the spa's sensory welcome.

I'm early because I want to enjoy the relaxation area, meditating in the dim lighting with the fireplace crackling, sinking into a comfortable chair while wrapped in a robe until my name is softly called for my service. I call it my Relaxation Prelude.

After my service, I'll revisit the same room to peacefully think about the next phase of my experience. The beautiful spa has a sauna, steam room, cold plunge, and all the amenities to continue the afterglow of my immersive experience.

The reason I pay a premium for this type of massage is all the value-added extras that come with the three hours I set aside to reset and relax. However, it took me several visits to explore and understand how I could turn my time into a premium experience.

During my last visit, as I was getting ready after my service, I watched another woman walk from the sauna to the showers, looking a bit confused. I took the time to show her how to turn on the rain-like showerheads and change the color of the steam room. I showed her the wraps available for the cold plunge and a cooler of eucalyptus-scented face towels. I wanted her to have the same experience I was having by understanding all the amenities.

I was already a loyalist to this spa. She seemed thankful but still unprepared to enjoy the experience she had invested in to relax and rejuvenate.

The spa had created an exceptional experience, but had it helped every customer discover its full value?

Luxury spa relaxation lounge with warm lighting

Proper Customer Onboarding Is an Unlock to Loyalty

A company has only one opportunity to make a first impression. The minute a new customer engages with your brand, the onboarding process should start.

Imagine a staff member who has worked at the spa for a year. She's walked into the spa over 300 times and has seen the same amenities and the same beautiful artwork, yet it has all become mundane. What feels ordinary to an employee may be extraordinary to a first-time customer, if someone helps them discover it.

This is why staff should know from the reservation details or ask, "Is this your first time here?" A first-timer should be cared for in a way that encourages future purchases. Over time, I learned the "secrets" of the spa, such as what items to bring, what time to arrive, and how to use the cold plunge.

I onboarded myself.

And that raises an important question for operators: How much of the value you've created are your customers actually experiencing?

1. Onboarding Starts Even Before Payment to Build Trust

The early phases of customer engagement are often overlooked as an opportunity to start building trust. Brands that work so hard to sell and get payment miss the earliest stages of building trust in their products or services before actually receiving payment.

One of my favorite quotes comes from Chip Heath and Dan Heath in The Power of Moments (2017):

"Defining moments shape our lives, but we don't have to wait for them to happen. We can be the authors of them."

Helping customers understand how to use a product, take advantage of its benefits, and feel informed should start before receiving payment.

Onboarding isn't simply a process that follows a purchase. It's an opportunity to reinforce why the customer should make that purchase in the first place.

2. Purchase Decision Reinforcement

Specifically in the service industry, and for a premium service priced above the market average, customers need a positive sense of purchase decision reinforcement.

When customers quickly experience the value they were promised, they have a stronger reason to continue the relationship.

After a very long travel day, think about the sense of magic that embraces you when you see the gates of the Magic Kingdom. That's immediate purchase decision reinforcement.

For premium brands, those early moments matter. Customers aren't just evaluating the product or service. They're deciding whether the entire experience justifies what they paid.

3. Positive and Consistent Experiences Encourage Repeat Behavior

It's natural that a positive experience will invoke a desire to repeat it. How many times have you visited a restaurant, only to return and talk about the great experience you had the last time?

The consistency of a good experience reinforces ongoing loyalty to the brand.

Over the years, the unboxing experience of buying Apple products has consistently been positive. The packaging protects the products inside and creates a positive experience, whether it's an Apple Watch, iPod, iPhone, or another product.

A great first experience creates the desire to return. Consistency gives customers the confidence that the next experience will be just as good.

If your data shows that you don't have repeat purchasers, you have lower-than-industry-average survey response rates or NPS, or customers take longer to repurchase than they do with competitors, you may have an onboarding issue. This is especially important if you offer a premium product or service in your industry.

Before assuming the problem is price, product quality, or competition, it's worth examining whether customers fully understood and experienced the value you intended to deliver.

Three Ways to Identify Gaps in Customer Onboarding

Drawing on years of hands-on CX work across industries, here are three proven methods I use to surface the hidden gaps that quietly erode the onboarding experience.

1. Become the Customer

Use the most objective first-time experience possible as a prospective customer. Visit and search the website, call the 800 number, and purchase products.

You don't have to go through the expense of filming an episode of Undercover Boss to mystery shop your own business. Think like a customer and take the time to engage with your brand.

Pay particular attention to what you have to figure out on your own. Those moments may reveal opportunities to improve the first-time experience.

2. Map the First-Time Customer's Journey

Map every touchpoint, from initial interest through the first purchase. Look for opportunities to educate and build trust, as well as onboarding problems or gaps. Both are important.

Don't just map what the company does. Consider what the customer knows, understands, and feels at each step.

3. Study Customers Who Never Came Back

Some of the most valuable insights come from customers who made one purchase and never returned.

Analyze first-time buyers who did not make a second purchase within the expected buying cycle. Where possible, ask customers why they didn't return. Once you get the answers, actually create an improvement plan.

Companies work so hard to get new customers, but onboarding is often overlooked as an element of keeping customers.


We focus on Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): What does it cost us to acquire a customer?

And we focus on Customer Retention Cost (CRC): What does it cost us to retain customers?

But what about Customer Onboarding Cost (COC)? What are we investing in the customer's first experience?

Perhaps the more important question isn't simply what onboarding costs, but what it costs the business when onboarding doesn't happen.

I'm not sure if the woman I met at the spa that day ever returned. Perhaps she did because a fellow customer helped her understand how to make the most of her experience. Or maybe she didn't because she found the premium luxury experience wasn't worth the cost.

Bring the Customer Experience Conversation to Your Next Event

Great customer experiences don't happen by accident. They are the result of intentional systems, empowered employees, and a commitment to making the customer the hero of the story.

Salena Scardina, founder of HeroCX® and TEDx speaker, brings these ideas to life through engaging keynotes and leadership presentations.

Explore Speaking Engagements

Ready to apply these ideas?

Book a complimentary 30-minute CX strategy session with Salena.

Book a Session